Friday, June 12, 2009
Death for Honour
In the rural areas of India, killing for honour is still widely practised. In the video, a mother strangled her pregnant daughter of six months and her daughter’s lover to death. A newly married couple were shot to death by the bride’s father, relatives and brother. Also, a 19 year old woman was thrown to death in a canal, but survived. Their offence was marrying outside of their caste.
In the past, Hindus were defined by their caste. The caste system divided the society and dictated that a person born into one caste is not allowed to change castes or mix with members of other castes. Therefore, the lower castes were forbidden to marry the upper castes. Today, the caste system which has been made illegal for more than fifty years has prompted the majority of Indian citizens to eradicate the division in society and treat all as equal. To the minority, however, the caste system which is a part of their culture is still being practised.
The parents, relatives and siblings, who murdered their kin, share the same belief that marrying outside of their caste brings great dishonour to the family. In their opinion, such an act of betrayal to one’s caste and shame to the family deserves a severe punishment in the form of murder. Often, the families’ communities largely support these murders.
These acts of murder clearly illustrates that culture has a huge influence on society. In the abovementioned society, their cultural beliefs represent their understanding about what is true. Heavily influenced by their ancestors practise of only marrying into ones caste, the society has created an understanding that this practise is true and should be followed. Not doing so, will cause shame, dishonour and ridicule to the family by society. And thus, they feel that the offenders should be punished severely regardless of the questions on morality and human rights it poses.
The practise of honour killing transcends cultures and religions. It is committed for various offences such as refusal to follow religion, refusing arranged marriages, marital infidelity, pre-marital sex etc. Apart from India, the countries that commonly practise it are Egypt, Israel, Pakistan, Iraq, Iran and Afghanistan.
Though cultural values and beliefs should be practised and preserved through the passage of time, I believe that it should be done with proper understanding and accurate knowledge. Perhaps a lack of education and blind faith or misinterpretations of religious teachings with a personal agenda has promoted the idea of honour killings in many cultures and religions. I feel that the government of countries that practise honour killings should take steps to eradicate this practise by implementing stricter laws and educating the minority groups on eliminating this practise.
What are your views on honour killing?
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
I feel that there should be a stop for Honour killing. Just because of caste, religion and culture, people shouldn't live the life or choose the partner they want? Human beings do err. But instead of teaching them that it is wrong, killing is the only way? Hopefully, these old generations and those practising these, realize that killing is not the only way to solve a problem! I hope this stops for once and for all!(:
ReplyDeleteI agree with you that blind faith and misinterpretations of religious teachings are basis in explaining honour killings prevalent in the countries you mentioned such as Egypt, Pakistan, Iraq, Iran and Afganistan. The people who commit honor killings hide behind the pretext that it is a practise allowed in Islam to defend their honour by killing. There is however no basis in Islam to kill when someone refuse to follow the religion or refuse to an arrange marraige.
ReplyDeleteAs mentioned, societies that practice honor killing are mostly from rural countries that hold traditional values and beliefs. The majority of these people are poorly educated and therefore, heavily influenced by their ancestral beliefs.
ReplyDeleteI feel that they should not be judged too harshly for their actions as they are practicing what they believe to be true for fear of defying their culture. They are living in an environment where the society has dictated that the defiance of beliefs should be dealt with severely. This may have prompted them to commit these acts regardless of morality or compassion. However, their actions are morally wrong and they should not be dealt with lightly by the law.
As mentioned by the writer, the government has passed a law banning caste based honor killings. However, its practice is not widespread in India. Perhaps the government should take steps to improve this situation.
sometimes, these 'honour killings' are defined as such to attach a nobler purpose for the murder. rape for example. i remembered reading an article about a woman being raped by a man. instead of prosecuting the man, they killed the woman as being raped brought shame to her family. i don't think that is the real reason behind the killing. probably want to enforce the notion that males > females. fullocrap.
ReplyDeleteI do not believe in honour killing. Honour killings are done when religions, castes and cultures are felt to be threatened. I feel that when people kill people for the legitimate reasons not observing their "caste religion and culture", but personally it might have also been because of pride, because these people who broke the norms had courage to live the lives that they want, they did something that the others probably had wanted to do but feared to do. the reason for honour killing for those who performed the killing was more like a 'if i can't have that freedom, i will not let you have that freedom too'.
ReplyDeletemy view on honour killings...
ReplyDeleteit happens...
wat is right n wat is wrong is relative...different beliefs i guess...
u see...cultures, traditions, coustoms & caste these are structures, boundaries and limits created to provide security...
these are systerms or set of rules or even...laws...which are in place to provide security...i wont judge no more on this...its not them...its more than meets the eye...
Rafi, your statement on more than meets the eye is very vague. What other reasons than what has been addressed, might have prompted people to perform honour killings? Also you have stated that what is wrong is relative. In this case, people are committing a wrong under moral grounds and thus should be punished. I do not think that just because it happens, it should be dealt with lightly by the indian authorities.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteGovernment can't help to reduce the honour killing as most of it happens in rural areas. Those people who follow these culture blindly justify their act with religion. No religion teach to take one's life.
ReplyDeleteHorror killing or any cruelty against human should be eradicated, creating difference between humans based on cast or religion or any such factor and creating biased preferences portrays the level of illiteracy morality in the culture, Educational reforms stressing on equality should be in place for the future generations.
ReplyDelete